If this is correct, it does explain the bombardement period while Jupiter pulled back and created the asteroid belt that happens shortly after earth formation and the reason for earth water content. Also the planets orbits would be unstable and favor the crashes that form the Moon.
It also would point at another way to detect potential inner rocky planets with earth like water content, by first detecting 2 gas giants in resonance sufficiently away from the star.
If this process is necessary for the existance of an inner planetary system sufficiently far away from the star. our planetary system might be a rare configuration.